NPR
Thursday, June 7, 2012

Why Borders Failed While Barnes & Noble Survived

It appears to be all over for the Borders bookselling chain. Almost 11,000 employees will lose their jobs when the company closes its remaining 400 stores by the end of September. Though the two chains pioneered the book megastore business 40 years ago, Borders made some critical missteps over the years that cost it the business.
(Justin Sullivan)
Borders Group Inc., the nation's second-largest bookstore chain, announced that it will liquidate the company.
It appears to be all over for the Borders bookselling chain. The company will be liquidated — meaning sold off in pieces — and almost 11,000 employees will lose their jobs. The chain’s 400 remaining stores will close their doors by the end of September. The retailer’s first bookstore opened in Ann Arbor, Mich., 40 years ago. Along with competitor Barnes & Noble, Borders pioneered the book megastore business. But Borders made some critical missteps over the years that cost it the business. The vast tracts of retail space that Borders will soon vacate speak to a gargantuan business that essentially killed itself. At one time, size was its advantage. Borders built a reputation on offering a huge variety of books — tens of thousands of titles in a single store — at a time when most bookstores could afford to stock a fraction of that. Borders also had an early technical advantage: a superior inventory system that could optimize, and even predict, what consumers across the nation would buy. But in the mid-1990s, Borders lost its edge. “It made a pretty big bet in merchandising. [Borders] went heavy into CD music sales and DVD, just as the industry was going digital. And at that same time, Barnes & Noble was pulling back,” says Peter Wahlstrom, who tracks Barnes & Noble for the investment research firm Morningstar. He says Barnes & Noble also invested in beefing up its online sales. Eventually, it also developed its own e-reader, the Nook. Borders did not. Instead, it expanded its physical plant, refurbished its stores and outsourced its online sales operation to Amazon. “In our view, that was more like handing the keys over to a direct competitor,” Wahlstrom says. Indeed, outside a Borders bookstore in Arlington, Va., shoppers say they rarely buy books the old-fashioned way. “I’ll go to Borders to find a book, and then I’ll to go to Amazon to buy it, generally,” customer Jennifer Geier says. With so many people going online to buy books, Borders lost out. The last time it turned a profit was 2006. In February of this year, it filed for bankruptcy protection. Those who bemoaned the rise of bookselling giants might see irony in Border’s demise. With one of the major players gone, there might be some room, once again, for the little guys. “I think there are a bunch of different niches around that can still be sustained, but I don’t think there’s a need for the mass-book seller to be as prevalent or as apparent as they were five or 10 years ago,” Wahlstrom says. Wahlstrom says Borders is disappearing at a time when, as consumers, readers are more empowered than ever. He says he still reads paper books but also reads on his iPhone, computer or tablet. “Just as I’m probably device agnostic, I am supplier agnostic. I can go online, I can go to Barnes & Noble, I can go to Apple, or I can go to Google. Or I can borrow it from a friend or I can go to a library,” he says. Dan Raff, a management professor at The Wharton School, argues that smaller-town America will suffer from the loss of a chain bookstore. “The big-box store was a glorious thing while it lasted. To people in many parts of America, they were a kind of Aladdin’s cave,” Raff says. At Borders, people could access literary variety, contrary to smaller, independent bookstores. With Barnes & Noble staking its future on digital technology, Raff says, it’s likely the big bookstore will only live on in big cities. Copyright 2011 National Public Radio. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Categories

Business, NPR

Market Square Farmers' Market

URL: 
http://c295317.r17.cf1.rackcdn.com/EP6-6SEGD.mp3
Story: 

Pittsburgh’s farmers’ markets are unique to their surroundings. For the Downtown market at Market Square, the crowd tends to consist of working people on their lunch breaks, so you’ll find the typical farmers market produce along with prepared foods and a little music to enjoy while you eat. This week we talk to local singer-songwriter Joy Ike during the Downtown market’s Noontime Concert series.

Speaking Volumes: Dennis Yablonsky

URL: 
http://c295317.r17.cf1.rackcdn.com/EP6-6SEGC.mp3
Story: 

Allegheny Conference on Community Development CEO Dennis Yablonsky draws inspiration from stories of leadership and perseverance.

He recommends:

Sean Parnell, Outlaw Platoon

In combat, men measure up. Or don't. There are no second chances.

Reese Erlich

URL: 
http://c295317.r17.cf1.rackcdn.com/EP6-6SEGB.mp3
Story: 

Reese Erlich is a freelance journalist and the author of Conversations with Terrorists. We talk to him fresh from his latest trip to Libya, Syria and Tunisia, about what is currently unfolding in those countries as the ramifications of the “Arab Spring” continue to unfold.

 

Human Trafficking

URL: 
http://c295317.r17.cf1.rackcdn.com/EP6-6SEGA.mp3
Story: 

Human trafficking is one of the largest criminal enterprises in the world, affecting every country and cities large and small. Here in Pittsburgh, efforts are underway to combat the growing problem, but lawmakers have been slow to react and police are not always properly trained.

Privatization of Space Flight

URL: 
http://c295317.r17.cf1.rackcdn.com/EP6-5SEGB.mp3
Story: 

On May 22, SpaceX’s Falcon 9 launch vehicle delivered the Dragon C2 spacecraft into orbit. The spacecraft carried some simple cargo to the International Space Station, and then splashed down in the Pacific Ocean on May 31. That simple mission, though, proved the viability of privatized space flight, with enormous potential implications. We talk to Jay Apt, professor at CMU’s Tepper School of Business and Engineering and Public Policy, and former NASA astronaut who went on four shuttle missions, about what this means for space flight.

The Better End

URL: 
http://c295317.r17.cf1.rackcdn.com/EP6-5SEGA.mp3
Story: 

Medical technology can prolong our lives — even, sometimes, at a cost of great pain, or a loss of autonomy. Some would consider it worthwhile, while others would prefer a natural death to such a fate. Usually, though, when that choice is upon you, you’re not in a position to speak for yourself. Dr.

Average White Band

URL: 
http://c295317.r17.cf1.rackcdn.com/EP6-4SEGC.mp3
Story: 

The Average White Band, the ’70’s funk soul band, may be best known for their hit song, “Pick Up the Pieces.” They were the first white band to appear on Soul Train. Through the years they have performed at a number of venues in Pittsburgh. Part of their live album, Person to Person, was recorded at the Syria Mosque.

The Transit of Venus

URL: 
http://c295317.r17.cf1.rackcdn.com/EP6-4SEGB.mp3
Story: 

Once a century, the transit of Venus occurs in a pair. One took place in 2004, and the second will happen this week. After that, there won’t be another until 2117. Glenn Walsh from the Friends of the Zeiss and John Radzilowicz, Director of Science & Education at the Carnegie Science Center, join us to talk about this and other astronomical events that Pittsburghers may have to look forward to (weather permitting).

Is There a War on Science?

URL: 
http://c295317.r17.cf1.rackcdn.com/EP6-4SEGA.mp3
Story: 

What does science get us? How is it communicated and applied in the public square? How and why does the process go wrong? John Radzilowicz, Director of Science & Education at the Carnegie Science Center, will be presenting at tonight’s Café Scientifique to ask if there is a war on science in the United States. We’ll talk to him about how science is done, how it’s communicated, and how it’s used (and misused) in our society.